Donald Trump called Omarosa a dog. Is that racist, sexist, or both?

  发布时间:2024-09-22 01:20:22   作者:玩站小弟   我要评论
On Tuesday morning, President Donald Trump praised his chief of staff John Kelly for letting go of O 。

On Tuesday morning, President Donald Trump praised his chief of staff John Kelly for letting go of Omarosa Manigault Newman—or, in Trump’s words, “for quickly firing that dog!” That insult came after Manigault Newman embarked on book tour in which she’s been selling the claim that she’s heard a tape of Trump saying the N-word. Trump, meanwhile, has been using his Twitter page to depict the former Apprentice contestant as “wacky,” “crazed,” and a “lowlife.”

Dog marks a new low in this war of words. Some people are calling it sexist. Some are saying it’s racist. Some people think it’s neither, and it could always be both! So, what is it?

On Twitter, a user with the handle @conservogirl wrote that “according to the dictionary, [“dog”] is neither racist or sexist, and while unpleasant, in this instance the term fits. ‘a person regarded as unpleasant, contemptible, or wicked (used as a term of abuse).’ ” Unfortunately for our friend @conservogirl, words can have multiple definitions, and so we must press on.

In the right-wing Daily Wire, conservative gadfly Ben Shapiro noted that “Trump routinely suggests that people he doesn’t like are dogs.” Shapiro’s analysis: “That may make him a ridiculous practitioner of the English language, but it doesn’t make him a racist.”

He’s right that Trump compares people to dogs all the time, especially when they’re getting fired—HuffPost has assembled a compendium of tweets that show just that. But with just a couple of exceptions, Trump almost uses the formulation “like a dog,” comparingpeople like Glenn Beck, Chuck Todd, and Erick Erickson todogs rather than claiming they aredogs.

Advertisement

In addition to Tuesday’s Omarosa tweet, I’ve been able to find three instances in which Trump called someone a dog, rather than just comparing them to one, on Twitter. The first came in 2013, when, as part of a feud with Mac Miller about the rapper’s song “Donald Trump,” the future president wrote, “I’m now going to teach you a big boy lesson about lawsuits and finance. You ungrateful dog!” In 2015, Trump called David Axelrod a dog for criticizing him on Fox News “even after I made a big contribution to his charity.”

Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement

While Trump doesn’t always use dogas a sexist insult, he does use it to insult women’s looks.
Consider this attack on Arianna Huffington in 2015:

Advertisement

Also, in 2011, New York Times columnist Gail Collins wrote about Trump sending her a copy of a column in which she’d called him a “financially embattled thousandaire”; he’d circled her picture and written “The Face of a Dog!”

Advertisement

And as long as we’re talking dictionary definitions, we should note for @conservogirl’s sake that Oxford, the same dictionary that defines dogas someone “unpleasant, contemptible, or wicked,” offers this alternative definition: “an unattractive woman.” It’s no coincidence that the word bitchrefers to both female dogs and cold, difficult women.

Advertisement

Calling Manigault Newman a dog also aligns with the way Trump expresses his racism. He has famously called immigrants “animals” in an attempt to deprive them of their humanity. And he’s not the only one: Associating people of color, especially black people, with animals is a tried-and-true strategy among those who believe whites belong at the top of a racial hierarchy. The word dogin particular is a common addendum to pejorative racial and ethnic descriptors.

Advertisement Advertisement

With evidence to support both racism and sexism in the use of the word dog, and taking into account Trump’s historical contempt for women and black people, it’s safe to say that the answer to the “sexist or racist?” quandary is “both.” The theory of intersectional oppression holds that both racism and sexism are multidimensional. A black woman like Manigault Newman doesn’t experience the same kind of sexism a white or Asian-American woman does, and neither does she experience the same kind of racism a black man does. By labeling her a dog, Trump called upon a very specific kind of anti-black sexism that comprises both the American history of enslaved black women being treated as livestock-like “breeders” and contemporary pop culture depictions of black women as angry, emasculating “bitches.” Thank Twitter’s character limit for forcing our bombastic president to smoosh such a broad and complex history of discrimination into one three-letter word.

Tweet Share Share Comment
  • Tag:

相关文章

  • World's first 18650

    The vast majority of our portable electronic gadgets, and the new wave of electric transportation, a
    2024-09-22
  • 七夕“浪漫大战”打响 青岛情侣消费看重性价比

    “全城热恋,倾城而动! ”“七夕狂欢,提前开抢! ”“浪漫七夕,你我相约。”虽然距离传统的中国情人节“七夕&rdqu
    2024-09-22
  • 3名驻雅全国人大代表昨日赴蓉报到

    雅安日报/北纬网讯第十三届全国人民代表大会第三次会议将于5月22日在北京召开。5月18日,3名驻雅全国人大代表邹瑾、庹庆明、毛珍芳启程赴蓉,与四川代表团的全国人大代表们汇合,于5月20日赴京参会。临行
    2024-09-22
  • 五月茶香依旧 茶叶交易火爆

    市场内交易火爆雅安日报/北纬网讯在经过前期明前茶、雨前茶的交易高峰后,名山区今年的春茶生产、销售已日趋平稳。近日,记者来到名山区世界茶都茶叶交易市场,看到此地一派热闹的景象。百余家茶叶销售商展示着自家
    2024-09-22
  • The local version of Project 2025 is already causing devastation.

    Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation’s toxic playbook for a second Trump administration, has so inf
    2024-09-22
  • 共绘绿美雷高画卷!广东省林业局发布“我在雷高有棵树”活动倡议

    共绘绿美雷高画卷!广东省林业局发布“我在雷高有棵树”活动倡议_南方+_南方plus3月5日,广东省林业局发布“我在雷高有棵树”活动倡议书,鼓励各单位积极组织党员干部职工募捐,并通过单位公众号、网站等平
    2024-09-22

最新评论