Despite Iran and climate deals, the the Doomsday Clock is still at three minutes to midnight.
Despite a major nuclear deal with Iran and a landmark global agreement on reducing greenhouse emissions, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists’famous “Doomsday Clock,” which had its annual unveiling Tuesday, remains unchanged at three minutes to midnight.
Introduced in 1947, the clock serves as “a metaphor for how close we are to destroying the planet,” as Bulletin’spublisher Rachel Bronson put it Tuesday. The closer the clock is set to midnight, the higher the risk. While initially focused on the risk of catastrophic nuclear war, the Bulletinhas expanded its remit in the past decade to include things like climate change and chemical weapons. The clock reached its closest to midnight at two minutes in 1953 following the first U.S. hydrogen bomb test. It reached a record 17 minutes to midnight in 1991 following the end of the Cold War. Last year, as my colleague Will Oremus wrote, it was set to three minutes, the closest to the world ending since 1984, due in large part to global failures to address the threat of climate change.
But while the impact of climate change was certainly undeniable during the hottest year on record, shouldn’t December’s climate agreement have moved the needle at least a little bit? At Tuesday’s clock unveiling ceremony in Washington, Sivan Kartha, a climate change expert on the Bulletin’s science and security board said, “We have to call Paris only a tentative success. The emission reduction pledges are manifestly, unequivocally inadequate” and “need to be matched with actions.”
As for nuclear risks, former U.N. Ambassador Thomas Pickering called the Iran nuclear deal merely “a relatively bright spot in a difficult horizon.” In addition to concerns about the implementation of that deal, the experts pointed to other global nuclear risks, including escalating tensions between nuclear superpowers Russia and the United States, which make further disarmament unlikely. India and Pakistan continue to expand their arsenals and global efforts to curb North Korea’s nuclear ambitions have failed dismally.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementWhile the Bulletin moved the clock back a minute following the election of Barack Obama, and his pledge to seek a world free of nuclear weapons, the experts have been disappointed by his record since then, in particular the massive ongoing U.S. nuclear modernization program. “What message does this send to non-nuclear weapons about our intentions?” asked the board’s chairman, physicist, and Slatecontributor Lawrence Krauss.
While all these threats and concerns are quite real, this seems a bit too dour. If we limit the discussion to nukes, it’s hard to argue that the world is at greater risk now than it was at the height of the Cold War. And as I’ve written before, I think the decision to expand the clock to non-nuclear threats dilutes the clock’s metaphorical power. It’s not that climate change isn’t a major threat, but unlike with nuclear war, we’re now no longer talking about the risk of a specific event. The world isn’t going to “prevent” climate change. It’s already happening and it’s going to get worse. The question is how much can we limit and prepare for its effects.
Advertisement AdvertisementIn 1963, the clock was set back from seven minutes to 12 minutes after the signing of the U.S.-Soviet partial test ban treaty. As the Bulletin’s website puts it, then the treaty represented “progress in at least slowing the arms race” and “awareness among the Soviets and United States that they need to work together to prevent nuclear annihilation.” Similarly, the Iran deal and the Paris agreement didn’t eliminate the risks of nuclear war or climate change, but represented tangible progress and an acknowledgment of risks. If the purpose is to urge leaders to address problems, that ought to be worth a minute or two.
Advertisement Tweet Share Share Comment相关文章
Tesla's big software update includes something called 'Night Curfew'
Tesla's latest car update is great news for parents who (unwisely?) let their kids borrow the car, a2024-09-21- 因囊中羞涩,李传勇谎称租住的房子是自己的,并伪造相关购房证明,进行变卖;张洪刚图便宜,贸然下手购买,结果上当受骗……8月29日 ,记者从市公安局雨城区分局河北派出所得知,李传勇因涉嫌诈骗已被刑事拘留。2024-09-21
- 广东数字农技云展示平台即将上线_南方+_南方plus功能丰富,超级实用!平台在手,农民不愁!8月15日,数字农技云展示小程序将正式推出。这是由南方农村报打造的农业技术推广小程序,有机整合了广东省农作物2024-09-21
- 雅安日报讯 正值我市灾后科学重建如火如荼之际,日前,南充市委常委、市纪委书记杨武秀带领南充市监督检查工作援建对接小组赴我市天全县,专门就援建监督检查工作进行对接。市委常委、市纪委书记刘锐陪同调研。在天2024-09-21
Campbell highlights Washington Declaration amid security concerns over Putin
U.S. Deputy Secretary of State Kurt Campbell, center, speaks during a joint press conference at the2024-09-21- 广州金农:多层养殖实现高效防疫,满产年可出栏30万头猪_南方+_南方plus非瘟暴发是国内养殖业发展的重要拐点,行业内产能恢复和扩张的需求催生了生猪多层养殖的新模式。广州金农现代农业有限公司以下简称“2024-09-21
最新评论